At it’s core, postmortem work is morbid, and being surrounded by death every day makes its practitioners a bit…odd. Or maybe we were weird from the get go. Regardless, one of our pastimes is discussing how we would kill ourselves*, i.e. “the best way to go.” Morbid, I know. Most of us favor carbon monoxide, which would be mine, too, but in times when I’m feeling spunky or vengeful, I tell my lab I’ve got the perfect poison and they’ll never find it in me. Good luck everybody. This usually elicits a laugh** and a request to die in some other state. My secret weapon, however, is about to be exposed.
* Suicide isn’t a laughing matter, and if you found your way here by Googling “how to kill yourself,” or feel suicidal, please contact the National Suicide Prevention Hotline or call them at 1-800-273-8255. You are loved, important, and not alone.
** Death is inherently sad, and myself and others, including people I know in emergency medicine, subscribe to the “if you don’t laugh, you’ll cry” theory. I try to do a lot of the former. I feel that every tear shed over a case takes with it a small part of me, a part that won’t grow back, and is forever lost. At some point I’m afraid I’d stop being “me,” and I don’t want to meet that person. No one does. So I laugh on the outside, and cry on the inside.
In 1902 Sir Arnold Theiler, the Godfather of veterinary science in South Africa, fed a plant thought to be a livestock poison to oxen and rabbits. They died. I’m sure the local farmers collectively rolled their eyes and thought “We’ve been telling you this for years, Dude, the plant’s poisonous.” There are slight differences in how species react to this poison, but in cattle, symptoms appear about 12 hours after ingestion, with the cow appearing uneasy and staggering. Respiration, salivation and urination are all increased, with evidence of hyperaesthesia (a heightened, painful sensitivity of the skin). Death may come quickly, or linger for a few days. It doesn’t sound pretty.
The scientific name of this short, green, and nondescript poisonous shrub is Dichapetalum cymosum, but is commonly called Gifblaar, a name given by the early Voortrekkers – Dutch pioneers to the Cape Colony of the early-to-mid 1800’s – and translates roughly as “poison leaf.” And poisonous it is, though from an unusual chemical, and one of the most simple molecules I’ve covered on this site: fluoroacetate.
Fluoroacaetate (FA), the sodium salt of fluoroacetic acid, is indeed simple. Replace a hydrogen from acetic acid (5% solutions of which are sold worldwide as vinegar) with a fluorine, and voilà , fluoroacetate. This one simple substitution renders something as innocuous as vinegar into a lethal poison able to kill a cow or a person. Isn’t nature, and chemistry, awesome?
The mechanism of FA toxicity is fascinating. Once ingested, FA is converted into fluorocitrate, which then binds to and inhibits the enzyme aconitase. So far this likely means nothing to you. Back in high school you undoubtedly learned about the citric acid cycle – or perhaps it was called the Kreb’s or TCA cycle – and how it takes acetyl-CoA, formed from the breakdown of carbohydrates, proteins, and fats, and converts it into energy in the form of ATP and a couple molecules of carbon dioxide. It’s a pretty major metabolic pathway if you need oxygen to live. The enzyme aconitase converts citrate to isocitrate, and inhibition with fluorocitrate , via FA, is like throwing a monkey wrench into our molecular machinery. The result is our cellular respiration is shut down, which in turn increases citric acid concentration in our blood and tissues. Excess citric acid leads to metabolic acidosis (a lowering of our blood pH), hypocalcaemia (low calcium), and eventual heart failure. Initial symptoms may be nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain, before progressing to more serious convulsions, respiratory failure, CNS depression, or cardiac failure. All of these are bad, unpleasant ways to die. And one more thing, there’s no antidote or magical Harry Potter bezoar, just supportive care.
And if there’s something that kills, there’s a good chance we’ve commercialized it. Enter 1080. The pesticide known as 1080 , if you haven’t already guessed, is…drum roll please...fluoroacetate. Widespread use of 1080 came during WWII when a Nazi scientist fled to England and shared this information. Though rarely used in the United States today, save for the poisoning of coyotes, it is still widely used in Australia to combat their rabbit, and other pest, problems. The indiscriminate nature of poisoning, coupled with its slow (some would call it inhumane) death, and lack of antidote, have caused 1080 to fall out of favor in most countries, but it is still used today in Mexico, Japan, Korea, New Zealand, and the aforementioned Australia.
So that’s my secret: fluoroacetate. It’s a painful, messy death. It would seriously suck, but 1) I don’t think my lab would detect it, 2) I don’t think our talented pathologists would pick up on it, 3) it’s not common here, hence 1 and 2. But that’s not to say you can’t detect FA, you can, especially in places where livestock are prone to Gifblaar poisoning. And just to make things weird: one unlikely biological specimen that can be used to detect FA and subsequent exposures and poisonings? Earwax.
Earwax can be dug out of a cow’s ear, thrown in a vial, and analyzed by headspace-GC/MS (much in the same way most forensic labs detect and confirm ethanol and other volatile substances in blood, urine, and brain). It sounds weird, but it makes sense. Collecting earwax is non-invasive, relatively easy (I think, I’m not into the cow scene), and is historical – it collects in earwax over time and you don’t have to worry as much about stability and half-lives. So if you’ll excuse me, it’s time for me to go clean my ears.
Selected references and readings:
- Steyn, D.G. “Gifblaar Poisoning. A summary of our present knowledge in respect of poisoning by Dichapetalum Cymosum.” 13th and 14th Reports of the Director of Veterinary Education and Research, Part I (1928): 187-194.
- Sherley, Miranda. “The Traditional Categories of Fluoroacetate Poisoning Signs and Symptoms Belie Substantial Underlying Similarities.” Toxicology Letters 151.3 (2004): 399-406.
- Goncharov, Nikolay V., Richard O. Jenkins, and Andrey S. Radilov. “Toxicology of Fluoroacetate: A Review, with Possible Directions for Therapy Research.” Journal of Applied Toxicology 26.2 (2006): 148-61.
- Shokry, Engy, FabrÃcio CarriÃ£o Dos Santos, Paulo Henrique Jorge Da Cunha, Maria Clorinda Soares Fioravanti, AntÃ´nio DionÃsio Feitosa Noronha Filho, Naiara Zedes Pereira, and Nelson Roberto Antoniosi Filho. “Earwax: A Clue to Discover Fluoroacetate Intoxication in Cattle.” Toxicon 137 (2017): 54-57.
I am nor so sure your astute poison would not arise the attention of at last some astute toxicologists, or even internal medicine specialists with a keen interest in poisons like myself. The symptoms slowly culminatng in an admittedly horrible, slow death are very similar to those of another TAC poison, rotenone.Rotenone eas forbidden in the European Union in 2009, but it is still extensively used in Australia to deal with the local rabbit scourge. Moreover, fluoroacetate poisoning may be considered something like a highly slowed cyanide or CO poisoning. With cyanide at non so high dose, symptoms peaking with cardiac failure are just dramatically accelerated compare with fluoroacetate. I am not so sure that no one would at least have at least some vague remembrance of bis undergraduate biochemistry courses.
It would certainly be suspected in Australia! Apart from its use as 1080, it occurs in a number of plants here, too, particularly in Western Australia. And I concur with your notes to the opening paragraph. My uncle was the analytical chemist at the Melbourne Coroner’s Court many decades ago. It got to him.
Sorry for the typing mistakes in my previous post: the so-said keyboards of cell phones are definitely too tiny.
Happily, fluoroacetate has not enjoyed the “it comes from Nature, so it can’t harm you” misperception. Something that occorred with “natural” (and toxicologically similar TCA poison) rotenone as an insecticide and pest-control agent – with special reference to politically correct biological agriculture, at last in my country. And so I remember dealing with several cases of rotenone poisoning in emergency wards when I was a young physician. Possibly the name fluoroacetate sounded too “chemical” to sound also “natural”.
Interesting. I didn’t know fluoroacetate was found in nature. But that leads to another question, how does the plant avoid poisoning itself?
Most plant poisons are secondary metabolites (not used in their own growth or development) or evolved for defense against herbivores – as long as they don’t interfere with plant’s processes, they’re OK.
Poisoning yourself with fluoroacetate is truly horrible way to kill yourself, and it is exquisitely detectable if you know what you are looking for (as there is no bacground of fluorinated metabolites in human body, and both fluorine NMR and MS with electron capture mass spectroscopy are exquisitely sensitive… And carbon monoxide provides characteristic pink coloration (one of the reasons smoked meat is pink even without curing with nitrite) and if you are revived you are likely to suffer brain damage resulting in blindness, speech impediment, staggering and dementia. I will take pass.
Truly a humane way to kill yourself – which is also perfectly undetectable if done right – is nitrogen asphyxiation. We don’t have receptors for hypoxia, the sense of suffocating comes from buildup of CO2/bicarbonate in bloodstream. Hence, if you inhale pure nitrogen (which I tried), you will not suffer except for a mild headache, and you black out within 10-20 seconds. There have been many deadly accidents with nitrogen in the industry, people walk into a reactor /room flushed with nitrogen and became disoriented and they collapsed before they knew what was happening. So if you have access to liquid nitrogen as I am sure you do, you can drain it into a little lunchbox cooler just like the construction crews do, sit in your parked car and make yourself comfortable by wearing warm clothes, it will take just few minutes…
Also, the volume expansion of nitrogen is about 700 while going from liquid to gas, so depending on the size of your car (subcompact works best) and the fact that you probably need several car volumes worth of displacement, to be sure, it might be better to actually fill up a mid-sized twelve pack cooler with liquid nitrogen, just to be sure. The empty cooler on the rear seat, and a moisture condensation will probably go unnoticed.
Truly we have some of the best names for plants that could kill us. These are fascinating stories for an enthusiastic newcomer to the world of poisonous plants such as I.
I have a couple of numbers that you could find interesting, Mr Holmes (blink, blink)
Being Dutch, I have to notify you that “Gifblaar” doesn’t translate to “poison leaf”. “Gif” translates to poison, yes, but “blaar” doesn’t translate to leaf. The Dutch word for leaf is “blad”. “Blaar” translates to blister. So Gifblaar translates to poison blister.
I am South African. Gifblaar is an Afrikaans word. Afrikaans deriving from the Dutch sttlers at the Cape of Good Hope. Gifblaar does translate from Afrikaans to english as Poison Leaf. A blister in Afrikaans is a blaas.
Language is amazing.
Pingback: The Poisonous ABCs: From Aconitine to Zetekitoxin | Nature's Poisons
Lovely blog you hhave here