Quick Commentary

Mushroom Week on Nature’s Poisons

Fly Agaric by unknown artist (public domain by CC0 1.0)

Fly Agaric by unknown artist (public domain by CC0 1.0)

Welcome to Mushroom Week on Nature’s Poisons, where I’ll highlight two poisonous mushrooms, one that severely sickens and one that can kill.  Check back on Tuesday and Thursday for the history, chemistry and science of these two fungi.  I plan on covering more poisonous mushrooms over time, so be patient, but if there’s one you’re just dying to know more about, just e-mail: naturespoisons@gmail.com or hit me up on twitter: @NaturesPoisons

I will start off by stating that I am not a mushrooming expert.  At all.  They call it mushroom hunting for a reason, not mushroom harvesting.  Hunting implies not only do you have to look for them, but there is an element of danger, too.  It is unwise to hunt for mushrooms unless you are properly trained in the identification of mushrooms, preferably from one-on-one instruction in the field with an expert or mycologist  – that’s a mushroom scientist.  There are so many “look-alikes” out there; those poisonous mushrooms that look just like a safe and delicious one, except for that one little thing.  There are a lot of “one little things” in life such that if you neglect them, they’ll come come back to haunt you.  Mushrooms are like that.

There are also many, many old wives tales and myths about what is a safe or poisonous mushroom, with most of them being false.  Here’s a few of them that I’ve heard and read:

1. Cooking a mushroom will make it safe to eat.
– Ummm….No.  Cooking and heating can do a lot of things, like denature peptides and proteins – common poisons and venoms – but not so much with mushroom-based poisons.  You’ll read later this week about a drastic poisoning that occurred after cooking and consuming mushrooms.

2. Poisonous mushrooms taste bad.
– No.  There are safe mushrooms that taste like crap, and poisonous ones that taste good.  That’s how people are able to actually consume enough to become ill.  If they tasted bad, I’d like to believe that people would stop eating them.  Poisoning victims often claim that the mushrooms tasted fine.

3. Poisonous mushrooms have pointy caps
– If you go by this and assume that non-pointy capped mushrooms are safe, you’d be taking the risk of killing yourself.  Just look at the “death cap” mushroom, Amanita phalloides.  See, not pointy.  It’s not called the “death pointy cap”, now is it.  And the name “death cap” is well earned, so yeah, it’s poisonous.

Amanita phalloides by Archenzo (CC 3.0)

Amanita phalloides by Archenzo (CC 3.0)

4. White mushrooms are safe to eat.
– Really?  That “death cap” looks pretty white to me.

5. And the converse, poisonous mushrooms are brightly colored
– Same thing.  Look at the “death cap”.  No pretty colors there.

6. Insects stay away from poisonous mushrooms.
– No.  Insects will lay eggs and crawl around just about anything.

7. And my favorite: poisonous mushrooms will turn a silver spoon black
– I don’t even know how to respond to this one.  All sorts of no.

The point of all this is to show that there is no simple “test” to distinguish edible from poisonous mushrooms.  Doing so can only be done by careful analysis of physical characteristics, area and region of growth, and season – preferably by an expert.

If you feel like you want to explore the realm of mushroom hunting, a good place to start would be the North American Mycological Association.  Join a local mushrooming club!  And if you think you have been poisoned, stop reading, put down the internet, and call your local Poison Control Center (the number is stored in your phone, right?  No?  It takes less than a minute.  I’ll wait.) or the American Association of Poison Control Centers at  1-800-222-1222.

So stay safe, and check back on Tuesday and Thursday for all sorts of mushroom poison/science/history goodness.

Tuesday: Orellanine: Kidney Failure by Mushroom
Thursday: Coprine: Alcohol Poisoning From Mushrooms?

** Homepage featured image of Amanita flavaconia by Don Kelloway (CC-BY-ND 2.0) **

5 thoughts on “Mushroom Week on Nature’s Poisons

  1. Pingback: Orellanine: Kidney Failure by Mushroom | Nature's Poisons

  2. Pingback: Coprine: Alcohol Poisoning From Mushrooms? | Nature's Poisons

  3. I would recommend to any aspiring wild mushroom pickers to be very conservative and limit himself at first to bolete mushrooms, (maybe also big parasols) because they are quite characteristic, and similar-looking mushrooms are not deadly. You definitely need someone experienced to go with you couple times and actually show you what you may pick, and explain the important basics (don’t put mushrooms into a closed plastic bag, don’t drink alcohol if you have a mushroom dish, clean and cut the mushrooms as soon as you get home and use them up very soon but don’t overeat on several pounds of mushrooms etc.). Chanterells and bleeding milkcaps are also fairly hard to mistake but people get over-enthusiastic…

Leave a Reply to haridasgowra Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s